Do Bath And Body Works Wallflowers Fit In Yankee Candle?

Plug-in home fragrances like Wallflowers and Scented Warmers have risen in popularity over the past decade as an easy way to keep your home smelling fresh. Brands like Bath & Body Works and Yankee Candle offer a wide variety of scents to appeal to any preference, and without the safety risks of keeping candles lit. Wallflowers in particular have developed a cult following, with customers eager to collect the latest seasonal fragrances. But with two major brands offering similar products, many consumers wonder if they can use Wallflowers in a Yankee Candle or vice versa. In this article, we’ll take a detailed look at the similarities and differences between Wallflowers and Yankee Candles to see if they are interchangeable.

Table of Contents

What are Wallflowers?

Wallflowers are electric fragrance diffusers created by Bath and Body Works that are designed to release a diffused fragrance in a space as a gentle air freshener. They consist of a fragrance oil contained in a plastic tube holder that sits in a small wall plugin. The plugin heats the fragrance oil gently to diffuse the scent into the surrounding air.

Wallflowers were first introduced by Bath and Body Works in 2003 and quickly became popular for their wide range of fragrance options and affordable prices. The Wallflower system allows the scent to be continuously diffused when plugged in, providing lasting home fragrance. With different fragrance options available in each collection, consumers can choose scents that fit their personal tastes and switch them out seasonally.

Today, Bath and Body Works offers over 80 Wallflower fragrance options across various scent categories like floral, fruity, herbal, baking, and seasonal scents. The fragrance oils are proprietary blends created by Bath and Body Works in-house perfumers. New collections are released frequently with limited edition seasonal scents for major holidays and occasions throughout the year.

What are Yankee Candles?

Yankee Candles are a popular brand of scented candles, founded in 1969 in Massachusetts. In addition to their classic jar candles, Yankee Candles also offer a wide variety of home fragrance products. One of their most popular items is the ScentPlug fragrance warmer.

The Yankee Candle ScentPlug works by melting a scented wax cartridge to release fragrance. To use it, you plug in the warmer, place a ScentPlug cartridge on top, and turn it on. The warmer gently heats the wax to melt it just enough to disperse the fragrance into the air. ScentPlugs come in a wide variety of Yankee Candle’s signature fragrances like Clean Cotton, Lavender Vanilla, Lemon Lavender, and more.

The ScentPlug system allows you to switch out fragrances by replacing the wax cartridge. It provides fragrance without having an open flame or burning a candle. Yankee Candle offers an automated cartridge delivery subscription service to send new ScentPlugs on a regular basis.

Overall, Yankee Candle ScentPlugs provide a convenient, mess-free way to fill your home with your favorite scents.

Comparing the Design

Wallflowers and Yankee Candle plug-ins have some key differences when it comes to their physical design and construction.

Wallflower fragrance plug-ins are plastic cubes that are approximately 2 inches wide on each side. They have a flat back and an open front where the fragrance emerges. Inside there is a wick saturated with fragrance oil. Wallflowers are designed to plug into a Wallflower electric warmer unit that heats the wick to diffuse the fragrance.

Yankee Candle plugin refills, also called tart warmers, are small rounded or square-shaped tarts of wax infused with fragrance. They are about 1-2 inches wide. Yankee tart warmers are meant to sit on top of a Yankee Candle tart burner which melts the wax using a small light bulb to release the scent. The wax warmer tarts are disposable while the warmer unit is reusable.

So in construction, Wallflowers use a plastic fragrance plug-in and Yankee Candles use a wax-based tart. The delivery methods also differ with Wallflowers using an electrically heated warmer and Yankee using a small light bulb warmer.

Comparing Fragrances

When it comes to fragrances, both Bath & Body Works and Yankee Candle offer a wide variety of scents to choose from. However, there are some key differences between the two brands.

Bath & Body Works has over 100 different Wallflower fragrance options available at any given time. The fragrances span a range of categories including florals, bakery, fresh & clean, and fruity scents. Most of the fragrances are proprietary fragrance blends developed by Bath & Body Works. The fragrances tend to be lighter, sweeter, and more playful compared to other brands.

Yankee Candle also has a large fragrance selection with over 200+ scent options for their candles. They offer more classic and natural scents across categories like floral, spice, citrus, and woody fragrances. Many of their fragrances are inspired by real-life places, memories, and experiences. The fragrances tend to be more authentic, robust, and long-lasting compared to Wallflowers.

When it comes to fragrance quality and performance, customers tend to rate Yankee Candle slightly higher than Bath & Body Works. Yankee Candle fragrances often feature higher concentrations of essential oils and natural ingredients. Their scents are designed to fill large living spaces. By contrast, Wallflower fragrances are lighter in nature and made for smaller rooms. However, both offer high-quality scents with passionate fan bases.

Comparing Performance

When it comes to performance, there are a few key factors to consider: scent throw, longevity, and coverage area.

Scent throw refers to how well the fragrance is dispersed into a room. Yankee Candles are known for their excellent scent throw that can fill up a whole room or even a home. The large jar candles have multiple wicks that help disperse the fragrance. Wallflowers, on the other hand, have a more subtle yet consistent scent throw. They won’t make as strong of an aromatic impact as a Yankee Candle, but they will continuously freshen a room.

In terms of longevity, Yankee Candles tend to last longer, with estimates of 110-150 hours of burn time for large jars. Wallflowers last about 30-45 days when used continuously. However, Wallflowers are designed for modular use, where you replace the fragrance refill, allowing for ongoing use. The longevity of Wallflowers comes from replacing the refills.

When it comes to coverage area, Yankee Candles are better at filling large spaces, while a single Wallflower is ideal for small to medium-sized rooms of up to 325 square feet. The wicks and wax pool of the Yankee Candle allow it to disperse fragrance better than the lower-heat electric warmer used for Wallflowers. You can increase coverage with Wallflowers by using multiple units in larger spaces.

Overall, Yankee Candles offer stronger scent throw and longer burn times but Wallflowers provide continuous fragrance coverage for a space over time. It comes down to the size of the space and the type of fragrance experience you desire.

Can You Use Wallflowers in Yankee Candles?

When it comes to physical compatibility, Wallflowers and Yankee Candles are designed differently. Wallflowers are a plastic plug-in fragrance refill designed specifically for Bath & Body Works fragrance plug-ins. The fragrance oil is contained in a small vial inside the plug-in. Yankee Candles, on the other hand, are traditional wax candles meant to sit inside a jar or other candle holder.

While you can physically place a Wallflower plug into a Yankee Candle jar, the performance results will be poor. Since Wallflowers don’t contain a wick, they cannot be lit like a traditional candle. The fragrance oil also evaporates through the plug-in vial differently compared to melting wax. Additionally, the Yankee Candle jar is not designed to disperse a Wallflower’s fragrance optimally. You would likely experience an uneven, weak fragrance.

For best results, it’s recommended to use Wallflowers with Bath & Body Works plug-ins they are designed for, and Yankee Candles within their intended jars and holders. While not ideal, you can attempt using Wallflowers in Yankee jars, but the performance and scent throw will be diminished.

Pros and Cons of Each

Both Wallflowers and Yankee Candles have their own unique advantages and disadvantages to consider:

Wallflowers Pros:

Come in a wide variety of scents
Relatively affordable
Easy to use – just plug into an electrical outlet
Refills are inexpensive
Small and discreet

Wallflowers Cons:

Limited fragrance throw compared to candles
Refills don’t last as long as a candle
Requires access to an outlet
Plastic aroma holders less decorative than ceramic candles

Yankee Candles Pros:

Strong fragrance throw fills a whole room
Long burn times – candles last weeks or months
No outlet required
Aesthetically pleasing with decorative jars

Yankee Candles Cons:

More expensive than Wallflowers
Limited scent varieties compared to Wallflowers
Requires vigilance – can’t be left burning unattended
Wax and wicks require maintenance while burning

Cost Comparison

When considering the costs of Wallflowers compared to Yankee Candles, there are a few factors to take into account:

Upfront Costs: The upfront cost of a Wallflower starter kit (plug-in and bulb) is typically $5-$10. Yankee Candle starters range from $10 for plastic to $20+ for ceramic warmers. So the starter costs are lower for Wallflowers.

Ongoing Costs: Individual Wallflower refills generally cost $3-$7 each and last about 30 days. Yankee Candle tumbler candles cost $15-$27 and provide 60-75 hours of fragrance. So while Wallflowers have a lower upfront cost, Yankee Candles tend to provide more hours of fragrance for the money when looking at ongoing costs.

Deals and Sales: Both Wallflowers and Yankee Candles frequently offer sales promotions. Yankee Candle often has deals like “Buy 2 Get 2 Free” on tumbler candles, which helps lower the cost per candle significantly. Bath & Body Works also runs frequent sales like “5 for $24” on Wallflower refills. So taking advantage of sales pricing can help lower costs for both options.

Overall, Wallflowers tend to be more budget-friendly for upfront starter kit costs. But Yankee Candles can provide more fragrance for your money over time, especially when sales are taken into account. So assess your usage and budget preferences when deciding.

Conclusion

Wallflowers and Yankee Candles both have their own pros and cons to consider. Yankee Candles offer a wider variety of sizes and fragrance options, while Wallflowers tend to be more affordable and convenient to use. Which is right for you depends on your specific needs and preferences.

If you’re looking for a classic candle experience with strong fragrance and a wider selection, Yankee Candles are likely the better choice. Their larger jars can fill an entire room with fragrance for up to 150 hours. They offer a more traditional candle-burning experience.

For a convenient, mess-free, and budget-friendly option, Wallflowers make an excellent choice. Their automated, electric fragrance delivery system makes it easy to enjoy home fragrance without lighting a wick. The inexpensive refills also make Wallflowers very affordable to maintain.

At the end of the day, Yankee Candle vs Wallflower comes down to the specific benefits you’re looking for. Yankee Candles provide a time-tested candle experience with strong scents, while Wallflowers offer effortless, electric home fragrance on a budget. Consider which factors are most important to you when deciding which option to choose.